Former Winslow church treasurer ordered to pay back £414k after parish thefts
A former church treasurer in Winslow who stole from the parish has now been ordered to pay back £414.994.73.
Terence Capstick, aged 77, of Park Road, Winslow, was ordered to pay back £414.994.73 to organisations in relation to his long-standing theft scheme.
He was told he must repay the six-figure total at a POCA (Proceeds of Crime Act 2002) hearing at Aylesbury Crown Court on Friday.
Two years earlier, Capstick was sentenced to four years in jail for two counts of fraud by abuse of position. His convictions related to money he took out of the accounts of Winslow Parish Church and the Rogers Free Educational Trust, a Winslow-based charity.


Investigating officer Accredited Financial Investigator Hannah Mitchell of the South East Cyber Crime Unit said: “I am so pleased that Capstick has been ordered to pay back this substantial amount of money and that all of it has been directed back to the victim organisations, being the first case of its kind.
“Capstick defrauded a vast amount of money through his position as treasurer across several years, completely betraying the trust placed on him by the community.
“The effect that his offending has had on this local rural community has been substantial and this case shows that if you involve yourself in this sort of criminality you can expect to not only be prosecuted but also pay back a considerable amount of money.”
Thames Valley Police advises that fraud cases can be reported to Action Fraud.
Detective Constable Ross Acland said following Capstick’s sentencing in 2025: “Capstick systematically abused the position of trust he was placed in through greed and solely for personal gain. Over the course of more than four years he has taken community funds earmarked for good causes and used them to fund his own lifestyle.