Defence and goals to Dolce and Gabbana; Is football just a business?
Football: the sport that unites nations and ties communities together, even whilst inspiring competition between each other. There are approximately 2700 registered senior footballers in the 5 major European leagues (the Premier League, LaLiga, Serie A, Ligue 1 and Bundesliga); there are ~2700 men responsible for bringing the public into harmony through the realm of sports. Surely, all of them deserve equal pay, as they all play the same game? The same 90 minutes? In this article, we will explore the economic side of football - how players earn the fortunes they are paid, the funding behind major “superclubs” and leagues, if pay truly is an accurate indicator of player performance, and how the felonious force of inequality is stripping the sport of the camaraderie that brought us together in the first place.


Erling Haaland: “The Viking” of Manchester City, had an astonishing 25/26 season, achieving an inexplicable xG of 25.39, while scoring 27 goals for his club. Such staggering statistics are clearly deserving of high wages, shown by the fact he has a base weekly salary of over £500,000 (excluding bonuses), approximating to a gross annual salary of £27 million. Following behind Haaland in pay is Bernardo Silva. The Portuguese right-winger had an xG of 3.2 last season, only scoring 2 goals. Silva had a annual gross salary of around £15 million. Much further down the payroll is Phil Foden, who plays as a midfielder. Last season he had an xG of 6.4, and had scored 7 goals. But, he had earned an annual salary of £11.7 million. These results beg the question - Is a player’s pay truly tied to their goal scoring ability at all? If value is tied to goals, why aren’t wages proportionate to goals scored too? These wages present the issue of marginal revenue product failure - praising the players we see scoring, but not the players working harder behind the scenes. In professions like football, it is extremely difficult to measure a player’s skill and value. We glorify and idolise our top goal scorers, who bring the exhilarating thrills to games, and overlook the significance of midfielders who control the pace of the entire game, grounding the rest of their team. We overlook the significance of our defenders, who inhibit the opposition’s attacks. We overlook our goalkeepers, easily scrutinising them for 2 conceded goals, but not revering them for the 16 goals they had saved. Attempting to put a price on these players is an extremely tedious and demanding ordeal, in turn making it hard to decide the wages each player deserves. So how can we make it fair for each player to earn pay they deserve? This side of football is highly subjective, and invites the idea that football may not be the meritocracy it seems to be.
Nevertheless, the inequality in pay is also caused by the promotion of “Brand Players” who bring in more popularity for the club, through tickets and merchandise. When you think of football, who comes to mind? Players like Cristiano Ronaldo, Messi, Mbappé, Ferran Torres, Neymar - names that any person would know, regardless if they are an avid football supporter, or haven’t even touched a football their entire lives. This is the side of football promoting superstar economics: alongside their athletic demeanours, they are advocates for major brands and commercial campaigns. Take Jude Bellingham for instance. In 2021, a year after his first England cap, he was worth over £2 million. He had scored 6 goals in the 21/22 season, having an xG of 3.5. In the 25/26 season, he now has a net worth £46 million, but he only has scored 9 goals all season with an xG of 7.2. Only scoring 3 goals more than 4 seasons ago, but earning 23 times more is appalling. But many fail to realise this - he is currently tied to 13 major brands like Lucozade, Louis Vuitton and Adidas. Being an ambassador for so many large corporations are bound to bring in more money for his club, making him worth far more than what his recent stats show. Other players may have far better statistics, but being from smaller clubs and not having as many sponsors prohibit them from being valued as highly as they deserve, making the corporate side of football lose its integrity due to its injustice. It isn’t just a contest of skill, but a competition of popularity.
For the average worker, these salaries seem like an absurd amount of money, inciting the question of where all of this money is coming from? How can these players consistently be paid multi-millions each year? Why are these salaries so high for all top-level footballers? The answer is clear: Income inflation. Over the past decade the prices of players have increased by 9%. The inflationary spiral stems from clubs generating money through broadcasting rights, and merchandising. The club’s increased budgets allows for agents to bid for higher pay. “Superclubs” see highly inflated wages are more viable options to buy players. Other members of the squad are then expecting an increase in their pay too. This eternal cycle leads to salaries inflating exponentially over the years, for all players. Major LaLiga club Real Madrid exemplify this income inflation through Ronaldo and Mbappe. CR7 was the top goal scorer in the season 10/11, earning a net annual income of €12 million. Last season, the top goal scorer was Kylian Mbappé, who estimatedly earned a shocking €80 million. They both are top performers, but one was paid over 6 times more, at the hands of inflation. As stated, this inflation affects all players. Fulham FC, a smaller club from the Premier League had Clint Dempsey as their top goal scorer in the 10/11 season, earning an average of £875,000. He was a very well renowned player, and is considered a legend at Fulham. Their top goal scorer of the 25/26 season was Harry Wilson, who had an average income of £1,125,000. Wages have increased on each side of the spectrum, where even the smaller, struggling clubs have had to inflate their player wages to keep up with the rest of the league. The shackles of inflation have proven themselves to be a key reason why wages are so high, beyond the performance of players and their reputations.
Smaller, struggling clubs find it hard to keep up with the increase in payrolls over the years. But inflation isn’t the only culprit found guilty for this issue; this problem also lies with divergence. Panning to a smaller football league in Europe, Ligue 1 is the top French football league, ranked as the 5th best in the world. Ligue 1 had recently had to turn to a D2C approach for broadcasting their games, due to the failure of the DAZN deal. Ligue 1 was forced to set up its own broadcasting service called ‘Ligue+’, which cost €66 million alone. The DAZN deal was projected to bring in €400 million, whilst Ligue+ could only potentially earn €166 million. This is because DAZN allowed for fans around the world to watch Ligue 1 games, but Ligue+ limits the reach of Ligue 1 mainly to French watchers. Due to this, the league winners only earn €30.1 million, and at the bottom of the table, they may only make €3.72 million. Smaller clubs turn to broadcasting deals for 40% of their income. In this world where inflation exists, this can lead to some of these French clubs risking bankruptcy. This explains the insane difference between some player’s salaries depending on the club they are signed with. These smaller clubs are faced with this inescapable and vicious cycle of barely fighting failure, whilst big name clubs, who already earn a lot, can afford to buy even more and increase the unbridgeable wealth gap between them. Football’s economic side illustrates the ‘Pareto inequality’; these ‘Superclubs’ are able to dominate the world of football, being that 20% that earn 80% of all revenue. They can attract myriads of fans globally, luring in higher volumes of ticket sales, only pushing them up this ladder of fame. Football becomes a business model, not a community, and the clubs who are already toiling face the hardest impacts.
But, Neglected clubs can never be mentioned in football without discussing women’s football. Women’s football is where the real-world socioeconomic problem of the gender pay gap can be seen without doubt. Women are paid considerably less than men, and are the biggest victim to this unfair system. Lets take Liverpool’s mens and womens team. In the 24/25 season, the women had a payroll allocation of around £3 million. There are 49 members of staff who work alongside the women’s team. The 9 directors of the entire club were paid £4.2 million alone. Is this an understandable statistic; that 9 people are paid over one million more than 49 others? Comparing to the men’s team, they had a payroll allocation of £137,540,000 in the same season. They had operating expenses of £651.3 million, while the women’s had expenses of £5.7 million. If women’s teams aren’t being funded enough, how can we expect them to grow their popularity? How can we argue that we want women’s and men’s teams to earn equal salaries when they aren’t even being invested in - nearly £600 million less than the men’s team? These clubs are being hindered of the ability to expand, and this leads to extraordinary female players being paid far less than what they should be getting. The Queen of football, Alexia Putellas, was one of the highest paid female footballers, playing for Barça Femení. Playing as a midfielder, she was earning a base annual salary of approximately €700,000. From the men’s team, playing the same position in midfield is Fermín López. He is the lowest paid midfielder from the team, amongst the likes of Pedri and Dani Olmo, yet he still has an annual base salary of €4 million. Women’s football shows the implications of the Matthew effect, and how these men’s teams who have been famous and growing for the past few years leave no room for women’s teams to earn money and be just as popular. The female counterparts within the sport are left to flounder with the lack of support.
Salaries in football are consequences of various economic factors and business-minded decisions - it is arguable that football has lost its focus on individual talent, to the allure of wealth. The priority of major clubs, superstar players, male teams in general all contribute to the unfairness of wages in the sport. This irreconcilable difference between pay and clubs needs to be mitigated. Our players deserve to be paid fairly. The felonious force of inequality that strips the sport of the camaraderie which brought us together in the first place must be stopped.