Bucks Council rejects calls for 'absolutely hated' blanket 20mph speed limits
Blanket 20mph speed limits are “absolutely hated” by residents and are being pushed for ideological rather than safety reasons, Buckinghamshire Council’s transport chief has claimed.
Cabinet member for transport Cllr Thomas Broom rejected calls for a blanket policy introducing 20mph limits outside schools during pick-up and drop-off times.
He said the council would continue to assess requests for lower speed limits on a case-by-case basis, based on evidence rather than introducing them automatically.
Cllr Broom said: “Anybody can apply for a road to go to 20 miles an hour, although that is based on evidence, not on ideology. We do not adopt the approach of some of our neighbouring councils in seeking to impose 20 mile an hour speed limits where people do not want them.”


Claiming blanket schemes had proved unpopular, he said: “Blanket implementations across the country have been massively opposed by local residents. They are absolutely hated.”
He also argued they would increase journey times by around 50 per cent compared with roads with a 30mph limit. The Conservative councillor said many concerns outside schools were caused by congestion rather than vehicle speeds.
“If you have a problem at a school that there’s too many cars and they’re all moving at five miles, 10 miles an hour, a 20 mile an hour speed limit does absolutely nothing to help either with the safety of pupils or with the easing of congestion outside that school,” he said.
Cllr Broom went on to describe the campaign for wider 20mph limits as “largely ideological”. “It is not based in practical reality. It is not based on a desire to make people safer,” he said.
“It is a desire to do down a perceived enemy in the motorist. And that is something that this council will not do.” He said Buckinghamshire Council wanted to give residents a choice over how they travelled and would continue to make decisions on speed limits based on “evidence and the reality of what is happening on the ground”.
However, Liberal Democrat councillor Justine Fulford urged the authority to introduce 20mph limits outside schools during pick-up and drop-off times without requiring schools to apply individually.
She said there were periods before congestion built up when vehicles were travelling at speeds that were too high for areas with large numbers of children.
“It’s too fast past a school when there are lots of very naive and traffic unaware pedestrians around,” she said. “It’s a very simple policy and it’s been very effective elsewhere… It works. Fatalities and serious injuries drop. It seems a great idea to me.”