'Extraordinary failure' Aylesbury Vale MPs react to claims HS2 could be delayed until 2039
MPs, with constituents in the Aylesbury Vale area, have all expressed their frustrations with the HS2 project after the Government confirmed the scheme’s opening is facing further significant delays.
Transport secretary Heidi Alexander told the House of Commons that trains are now expected to first operate on the high speed line between 2036-39.
It was also announced that the overall scheme could end up costing the Government around £102.7 billion.
HS2 has long proved controversial in the Aylesbury Vale area due to the amount of disruption to countryside land required to allow high speed tracks to pass through its towns and villages. These issues are amplified by the fact the project does not serve potential passengers within Buckinghamshire.


When HS2 was first formally discussed by the Government in 2010, a 2026 launch date was earmarked for the scheme, and it was allocated an initial budget of £32 billion in 2013.
MP for Buckingham and Bletchley, Callum Anderson, addressed the transport secretary’s comments in a statement yesterday. He said: “Today’s announcement from Heidi Alexander for Swindon South lays bare the extraordinary failure of successive Conservative governments to deliver HS2. Years of delays, spiralling costs and broken promises have left taxpayers footing the bill for a project that has caused huge disruption while delivering far less than originally promised.
“The news that HS2 will not be running until at least 2039 will come as a bitter blow to rural communities in north Buckinghamshire who have already suffered for far too long from the consequences of building and engineering works in our patch.”
Ms Alexander also revealed the project was going ahead with lower top speeds for the trains. Vehicles will now reach a maximum speed of 320km/h, 40 miles down on the original plans.


Mr Anderson also addressed concerns surrounding the disruption the construction has caused for local residents and businesses. Some owners have argued that the project’s road closures and noisy machinery has discouraged potential customers from visiting their sites. Mr Anderson said: “Locally, I have heard directly from residents in Quainton, Turweston and Westbury about the ongoing disruption HS2 construction has had on everyday life — including increased traffic, noise, road closures and the impact on rural businesses. I have also visited businesses affected by the works and understand the difficulties many continue to face.”
Mid Buckinghamshire MP Greg Smith, whose constituency includes Wendover, was equally frustrated with HS2’s impact on his constituents’ lives. He said: “The Transport Secretary delivered a Statement on HS2 today, confirming total costs for Phase One could breach £100 billion and that line speed would be reduced to 320kph. Utter madness that this bonkers railway was ever given the green light.”
Mr Smith also said that he thought the new maximum speeds will still cause significant disruption in his region and that “operational noise levels will be far too high”.
Aylesbury MP Laura Kyrke-Smith said she met with the current HS2 Ltd ceo and the rail minister following Ms Alexander’s announcement to raise local concerns that she has with the scheme.


Ms Kyrke-Smith said: “The fact that trains won't be running until 2036-39 feels like yet another blow, when we've already been putting up with the construction work for so long.
“The extent of mismanagement on the HS2 project under previous governments was staggering. This government’s investigations have found that tens of billions of pounds were needlessly wasted - on top of all the destruction of the environment and disruption to our town. But Ministers have set out that to cancel the scheme now would cost as much money as it would to complete it, and leave communities like ours with half-finished structures and a huge mess to clear up. So they've decided to press on and finish it.”
In reference to her meeting, she added: “I stressed the ongoing disruption and I raised several issues including the slow handover of land back to the Council once work is complete, and the slow progress on restoring the natural landscapes and our access to the countryside. I will be following up in writing again with HS2.
“I also raised again the need for a Rail Link from Aylesbury to Milton Keynes, which would be transformative for our town and a fraction of the cost of HS2. I will continue to push this with Ministers until we see progress.”