Thames Valley Police and Crime Commissioner Matthew Barber urges government to scrap 'mega-force' plans

PCC Matthew Barber has raised concerns around proposed plans to merge police forces across the country and create a new ‘mega-force’

In a joint letter to the Prime Minister, Matthew Barber, along with 30 other Police and Crime Commissioner’s, has warned that there is no evidence to show that larger forces perform better and raised concerns on the impact of mergers on local communities, victims and witnesses.

The letter comes ahead of a government-backed review of police force structures which could see the reduction of forces from 43 to as few as nine.

The government argues that having so many separate forces is unhelpful in tackling modern crime which is becoming more complex, with serious organised crime and new technologies.

It says that new advanced crime requires more cross-border collaboration, which works better if forces are merged.

The government also believes that this would create a more consistent police service across England and Wales.

But PCC Barber argues that local people are against the idea, and there has been no national consultation to discuss such a large-scale change.

He put out a survey earlier this year across the Thames Valley. Out of the 2,300 residents who responded, 75% opposed police force mergers.

Matthew Barber said: “Local people have sent a clear message. Three quarters of those who responded to our survey opposed force mergers, with concerns about police visibility, responding to local priorities and how resources would be allocated.

“Bigger police forces do not automatically mean better policing. I have consistently argued that the real issue is not force boundaries, but the way policing is funded.

“We should be investing in frontline policing, preventing crime, and ensuring victims and witnesses get the support they need, not spending millions on disruptive reorganisation.

“Creating ‘Mega forces’ covering vast areas risks weakening local accountability and taking policing further away from the communities it serves.”

“Any reform must deliver better policing and better value for the public. It should strengthen local accountability and community confidence, not create larger, more remote and more expensive structures.”

The full letter to the Prime Minister can be read here.

News you can trust since 1832
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice