Bucks Council keeps controversial planning policy after heated scrutiny meeting

A call for formal scrutiny of Buckinghamshire Council’s decision to stop publishing public comments on planning applications has been removed from a motion following a heated debate.

Councillors instead backed a substantially rewritten motion asking the cabinet member for planning to update a scrutiny committee on efforts to find a legally compliant and cost-effective solution.

The row concerns the council’s decision in March 2025 to stop displaying representations submitted by members of the public on its online planning portal.

An original motion proposed by Cllr Jonathan Waters and seconded by Cllr Mark Roberts called for the Growth, Infrastructure and Housing Select Committee to conduct a formal review of the change.

Jonathan Waters. Photo Credit Jonathan Watersplaceholder image
Jonathan Waters. Photo Credit Jonathan Waters

It asked the committee to investigate the circumstances behind the decision, compare Buckinghamshire’s approach with those of other councils and examine the options considered and consequences of the current system.

However, an amendment proposed by cabinet member for planning, Cllr Peter Strachan, and seconded by Cllr Michael Bracken replaced most of the motion’s wording.

The amendment removed the demand for a formal scrutiny review and instead asked Cllr Strachan to update the select committee on work to find a solution satisfying legal advice, data-protection law and taxpayers’ interests.

It also called for him to report to councillors “if and when” a solution was found and implement it swiftly, subject to an approved business case. The amendment was approved before the rewritten motion was carried by the council.

Buckinghamshire Council's full council meeting : Bucks Councilplaceholder image
Buckinghamshire Council's full council meeting : Bucks Council

Introducing his original proposal, Cllr Waters said the decision to stop publishing comments had affected the openness residents expected from the planning system.

He said: “Although this was treated at the time as an operational decision, its impact has been far wider. It changed the level of openness and transparency that residents had come to expect from the planning process and affected how this council is perceived.”

Cllr Waters said a public petition opposing the change had attracted more than 2,300 signatures. He added that Penn and Chepping Wycombe parish councils had passed motions expressing concern and written to the cabinet member describing the change as a “retrograde step” which risked creating a divide between Buckinghamshire Council and the communities it serves.

Cllr Waters acknowledged that the council had legitimate data-protection concerns but claimed more than 300 planning authorities continued to publish comments using different moderation and redaction systems.

He said: “Now that the current arrangements have been in place for more than a year, this is an appropriate time for the Growth, Infrastructure and Housing Select Committee to undertake a formal review.”

Cllr Roberts described the administration’s changes as a “wrecking amendment” which asked councillors to accept “vague assurances instead of evidence”.

Cllr Larisa Townsend said the original motion did not ask the council to disregard data-protection laws or publish privileged legal advice.

She said it sought an opportunity for councillors to examine the circumstances leading to the decision, the approaches adopted elsewhere and whether transparency could be improved lawfully.

“That is where the amended motion falls short,” she said.

Cllr Trevor Snaith quoted a resident who said: “I don’t think deleting every point and replacing it with the opposite can be called an amendment. Lenin would be impressed.”

Defending the council’s position, Cllr Strachan said that, following a data breach in early 2025, the council received “unequivocal” advice from a King’s Counsel to stop publishing personal data contained within comments.

He said the issue was not whether town and parish councils could see the representations, but the personal information embedded within them.

Cllr Strachan warned that a nearby authority had been fined £160,000 over a similar breach and said Buckinghamshire Council could not risk taxpayers’ money.

He said the authority processed approximately 1,000 planning applications each month and would potentially need a full-time team to moderate and redact the accompanying comments.

The council was continuing discussions with the Information Commissioner’s Office and speaking to providers of artificial-intelligence systems about whether technology could provide a solution, he added.

Cllr Strachan said: “We’re not risk-averse, but given the conditions we found ourselves in, we were obliged to do what we could do.”

Cllr David Moore backed the amendment, saying it would help find a solution while protecting taxpayers.

Cllr Christine Adali said residents felt “unheard”, “neglected” and “ignored”, adding that planning decisions often generated strong emotions.

Responding to the scale of the changes, Cllr Waters said: “When I opened up the document and saw with dismay the level of changes that had taken place on the original motion, negating really the whole purpose, I was shocked.”

News you can trust since 1832
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice