Developer appeals rejection of 57-home neighbourhood in Bucks dismissed as 'purely speculative'

Plans to build 57 homes on the edge of a Buckinghamshire village face council opposition, although the final decision now rests with a planning inspector.

Buckinghamshire Council’s West Area Planning Committee resolved that it would have refused the development off Thame Road, Longwick, had the authority retained the power to determine it.

Applicant Nicholas King Strategic Ltd appealed to the Planning Inspectorate after against the non-determination of the application.

Councillors therefore could not formally refuse permission, but were asked to establish the position the authority will take at the appeal.

Mid Buckinghamshire MP Greg Smith dismissed the project as 'purely speculative'. Image: Parliament TVplaceholder image
Mid Buckinghamshire MP Greg Smith dismissed the project as 'purely speculative'. Image: Parliament TV

The plans involve demolishing a house known as Chiltern, two residential caravans and structures within an existing yard before constructing 57 homes, a new access, public open space and associated infrastructure.

Officers initially recommended opposing the appeal only because a Section 106 legal agreement securing affordable housing and infrastructure had not been completed. However, councillors added another reason, arguing that the predominantly greenfield development would cause an unjustified expansion into the countryside on land outside Longwick’s settlement boundary and not allocated for housing.

Planning officer Lucy Bellinger said: “As a result [of the appeal], the local planning authority is no longer able to determine the application.

“What you’re being asked to resolve is what the decision would have been had we been in a position to still determine it. This will inform the council’s position in defending the appeal.”

Alan Divall, director at Walsingham Planning, told councillors on behalf of Nicholas King Homes that there was a “significant and acute need” for additional homes in western Buckinghamshire and across the county.

However, Princes Risborough ward councillor Matthew Walsh said Longwick had already accepted an “exceptional amount” of housing growth.

He said: “This application seeks another 57 houses on a site that is predominantly greenfield, outside the defined settlement boundary and on land not allocated for housing.”

Greg Smith, MP for Mid Buckinghamshire, called the proposal “purely speculative” and warned that approving it would undermine the plan-led system. He added: “This is the wrong development in the wrong place.”

One resident living beside the proposed development told the committee that neighbours feared losing their privacy. She said: “Windows from those houses look straight into our bedrooms, bathrooms, lounges and kitchens and overlook our gardens.”

Cllr Clive Harriss urged the committee to oppose the scheme. He said: “I’m fed up with coming to meetings and basically saying there’s no point in being here—we haven’t got a five-year land supply. If it gets thrown out at appeal, it gets thrown out at appeal.”

The committee resolved that it would have refused permission because of the site’s countryside location and the absence of an agreement securing affordable housing and necessary infrastructure.

News you can trust since 1832
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice