Charity's bid to block 170-home housing development in Aylesbury Vale dismissed by High Court

A legal challenge made by an environmental charity to prevent a 170-home development being constructed in Aylesbury Vale has been dismissed in a High Court hearing.

Earlier this year Wildfish lodged a formal legal challenge objecting to the construction of a new housing development in Maids Moreton.

Last week a judge dismissed claims made against Bucks Council and property company David Wilson Homes.

Wildfish launched the bid raising concerns with the potential for flooding in the area due to overspills from the River Great Ouse.

An artist's impression of what the development could look likeplaceholder image
An artist's impression of what the development could look like

A judge found that the council had followed legal planning procedure in approving the development by Walnut Drive And Foscote Road, but said no homes should be built until the sewage system in north Bucks was upgraded.

Wildfish argued the sewage system in the Buckingham region was failing its residents and noted that it had been given a ‘poor’ rating under the Water Framework Directive environmental standards. The charity argued that the structure run by Anglian Water cannot cope with extra demands.

Prior to the approval of the scheme, Anglian Water opposed the development citing concerns over the additional water flows that an extra 170 households would bring.

Following the hearing, Justin Neal, in-house solicitor at WildFish, said: “There is so much at stake here: we believe that as matters stand, there are inadequate safeguards to prevent the pollution of the River Great Ouse. A development that is built without first confirming that there is capacity at the sewage works is always going to be a bad idea. We are now considering whether we will appeal.”

Justice Lang dismissed the charity’s suggestion that elements of the application are misleading. A separate claim made by a resident over the biodiversity claims made in the planning application was also dismissed on all grounds.

Current plans regarding the new neighbourhood project state that 49 affordable homes will be constructed and the rest will be sold as private dwellings. According to the plans, the housing complex, which would be built on disused agricultural land, would be a biodiversity net gain. The new neighbourhood would include a mix of homes starting with one-bedroom properties, up to five-bedroom homes with everything in between.

News you can trust since 1832
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice